NotebookLM in Action: Takeaways from Testing Google's AI Research Assistant
NotebookLM in Action: Takeaways from Testing Google's AI Research Assistant
Google's NotebookLM stands out as one of the most impressive AI tools I've tested this year. This AI research assistant, powered by Gemini 1.5, digests and analyzes multiple sources to help users organize and connect information and gain deeper insights. Think of it as a highly capable research partner that can process PDFs, Google Docs, Google Slides, websites, audio files and even YouTube videos.
To gauge NotebookLM's usefulness, I carried out two experiments. The first explored how a teacher (or instructional coach) might use the tool to analyze and leverage educational content, while the second examined its value for student organization and learning.
The Notebook Guide
For my first experiment, I uploaded 50 sources about AI in K-12 education, including studies, reports, and articles from organizations like OECD, MIT, Brookings Institute, ISTE, Common Sense Media, and the World Economic Forum. NotebookLM quickly analyzed these materials and offered several ways to understand and interact with the content.
The Notebook Guide automatically generated a helpful summary of the sources and suggested high-level questions to explore. More impressive, NotebookLM's Briefing Doc synthesized key themes and important takeaways, accurately identifying that the content "spans diverse topics, including future trends in education, AI's role in education, and global competence development."
Here is an excerpt:
Main Themes
AI Integration in Education: This theme is prominent across the excerpts, highlighting the growing need to integrate AI literacy and applications into education. Sources argue that AI is no longer a futuristic concept but a present reality that educators and students must embrace.
The Evolving Educational Landscape: Excerpts like "2023 TeachingLearningReport.pdf" emphasize the changing nature of education, driven by technological advancements and evolving social and economic landscapes. Microcredentials, blurring learning modalities (like HyFlex models), and the emergence of technologies like generative AI are reshaping traditional educational practices.
Global Competence in the Age of AI: The need for students to develop global competence emerges as a crucial theme. Sources like "OECD big-picture-thinking-educating-global-competence.pdf" and "WEF_Defining_Education_4.0_2023.pdf" stress the importance of equipping students with skills like critical thinking, cross-cultural communication, and problem-solving to navigate an interconnected world increasingly influenced by AI.
What struck me most? NotebookLM's ability to maintain accuracy while processing such diverse content. The tool even noted when certain sources might need updates, questioning the relevance of a MIT study published before GPT-4's release.
It also led me to consider new or overlooked ideas. For instance, the Briefing Doc included the concept of blurring learning modalities, like HyFlex models. That caught my attention and I immediately started researching HyFlex models and their potential impact on the future of AI in education.
That said, the Audio Overview is the most intriguing NotebookLM feature. It transforms source content into a engaging podcast-style discussion between two realistic-sounding presenters. In my case, NotebookLM created a 19-minute podcast in about five minutes, synthesizing insights from my 50 sources.
I was momentarily awestruck as I listened to the natural-sounding banter between the hosts and their accurate and specific analysis of the sources I had provided. Both the principal themes they identified and the specific insights they provided were on the mark. Apart from a small error (mislabeling GPT-4o as GPT-4.0) there was little I could criticize.
Spanish Student
For my second experiment, I adopted the perspective of a high school Spanish student. I uploaded an an upper-level Spanish textbook along with notes and handouts focusing on challenging verb conjugations. NotebookLM's analysis proved particularly helpful for understanding complex grammar concepts.
The Briefing Doc organized key grammatical themes logically, explaining distinctions between various verb tenses while providing practical examples. The FAQ section offered clear explanations of irregular verbs and various past tense verb conjugations, and I found it helpful in understanding when and how to use certain verb tenses.
Even with mostly Spanish content, the audio overview maintained impressive accuracy. While the presenters' Spanish pronunciations weren't ideal, their explanations of Spanish verb conjugations remained clear and understandable.
Practical Applications for Teachers
NotebookLM offers educators several powerful capabilities:
Content Analysis: Teachers might upload curriculum materials, lesson resources, research articles, podcasts and YouTube presentations to gain new insights and connections. The tool can identify key themes and suggest new approaches to instruction.
Professional Development: Instructional coaches could create notebooks focused on recent research and specific teaching strategies or technologies, using the Briefing Doc feature to synthesize best practices from multiple sources.
Lesson Planning: Teachers could compile and analyze various resources about a topic, letting NotebookLM suggest connections and teaching approaches they might not have considered.
Resource Creation: The FAQ and Study Guide features can help generate student materials, discussion questions, and assessment items based on uploaded content.
Creative activities: Consider turning a scientific paper, historical document, literary analysis, and more, into an Audio Overview to engage students and provide an alternative means of absorbing and understanding information.
Student Applications
Students may find NotebookLM valuable for:
Study Support: Students could create subject-specific notebooks, using the FAQ feature to quiz themselves and the Briefing Doc to review key concepts.
Research Projects: The tool can analyze multiple sources and identify key themes, helping students understand complex topics more deeply.
Note Organization: The tool excels at connecting ideas across different sources, helping students build comprehensive understanding of topics.
Alternative Learning: Turning a book, scientific paper, historical document, and more into a podcast provides an alternative and engaging means of understanding information.
Limitations and Considerations
While NotebookLM impresses, there are important limitations. The tool currently processes only 50 sources per notebook, and it doesn't alert users when exceeding this limit. YouTube integration works only with videos containing transcripts, limiting access to valuable educational content like TED Talks. You can’t upload Word files, or other Microsoft file types, nor can you include “paid-only” web pages. The audio overviews, while engaging, remain available only in English, and users can't customize the presenters' tone (though you can customize the conversation focus).
Teachers and students should also note that NotebookLM may occasionally misinterpret source material or make connections that require verification. In my experiments, the tool sometimes emphasized unexpected themes or sources, suggesting users should always maintain critical oversight of its analysis.
Looking Ahead
NotebookLM points toward exciting possibilities for educational research and study. Teachers might create an "everything notebook" containing frequently used instructional resources, while students could develop subject-specific collections for ongoing reference. The tool's ability to synthesize information in multiple formats - written summaries, FAQs, audio discussions - lends itself well to supporting diverse learning preferences and needs.
Some practical tips for getting started:
1. Name source files clearly to help NotebookLM reference them accurately
2. Create separate notebooks for different subjects or projects to maintain organization
3. Use the "Ask" feature strategically to explore specific questions about your sources
4. Save important responses and insights using the note-taking feature
5. Consider how different output formats (Briefing Doc, FAQ, Audio) might serve various learning objectives
Use the Customize button in Audio Overview to focus on a source, topic, or audience
NotebookLM demonstrates how technology can support thoughtful academic work. Its ability to process, analyze, and present information in multiple formats can help both teachers and students engage more deeply with educational content and uncover new insights. While the tool has limitations, its potential to enhance research and learning deserves our attention.
AI Tools & News
SearchGPT Launches As ChatGPT’s Real-Time Search Feature - SearchEngine Journal
Grounding with Google Search - Gemini now supports real-time internet searches
Learn About - Experimental Google tool for deepening learning via a conversational learning companion
Supercharge Your Tech Plans with the AI Plan Analyzer - TCEA
The Evolution of Education Spurred On by AI - Tech&Learning
ChromeOS gets a big update with Quick Insert, Focus mode, and new AI features - The Verge
4 AI Tools For Education That Are Nothing Like ChatGPT - Tech&Learning
Can AI transform education? - Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
A Teacher Makes the Case for Using AI With English Learners - EdWeek
ElevenLabs’ Voice Design — create unique AI voices on demand
30 Things I’ve Learned About AI - Alberto Romero
Hello, you’re here because you said AI image editing was just like Photoshop
(Let’s put this sloppy, bad-faith argument to rest.) - The Verge
Find more AI tools, views, and how-to’s at tomdaccord.com